AgdaPkt 2016-11-07 Joint SA PFA - Laserfiche WebLink

Browse Search

From:CD-Jessica Manzi To:CD-Stacy Nicol Subject:Fw: Farm Hill Pilot Project Final Data Set & the October 5th Meeting Date:Tuesday, October 18, 2016 9:41:42 PM From: Sherine Khalil <> Sent: Monday, October 10, 2016 9:23 AM To: CD-Jessica Manzi Subject: Re: Farm Hill Pilot Project Final Data Set & the October 5th Meeting Hi Jessica, So are you saying that the interim report is from September 2015 to December 2015, and then the final report is data from January 2016 to September 2016? That doesn't make sense to review final data results and make a decision based on that when it doesn't include the entire pilot period. What would be the point of breaking that apart except for showing a month to month trend analysis to see how the data changed throughout the pilot as time passed by, which was not done by the Kimley and Horn? You are saying that you can look at the trend of the two reports, but did the city actually do that? Why wouldn't Kimley Horn actually prepare that comparison then? This does not make any sense. As far as the collision data, yes, you can wait 3 to 5 years after the change and compare to the previous 3-5 years prior to pilot, but you could have also just compared the previous year to the pilot year and compared that data, but they did not do that either. In addition, a question mark was used in the final report - what legitimate data warehouse manager submits a final report with a question mark to a city client? It's absurd. Why would they leave out the biggest factor of all - that the population has increased from pre-pilot through the pilot and continues to increase because the City approved all the new developments of commercial and residential buildings in downtown? How does 7 more people biking or 20 more people walking justify this pilot when we have over 77K in population before the development and it has grown?? Does anything about this report honestly, really, make sense to you? I know you are well educated and have had great experience in city urban planning and transportation. This can't possibly make sense to you. Though my specialty is in healthcare policy, management, finance and administration, I have a masters in public administration from NYU Wagner and worked with many urban planning professors and students as well. This data and how it is being used to make management decisions for a city that is in the middle of growth, is grossly negligent. From a research, statistical, and frankly, logical standpoint, the data analysis is severely lacking 8.A. - Page 67