Laserfiche WebLink
7.A. - Page 110 of 285 <br />2019 Energy Efficiency Ordinance Cost-effectiveness Study <br />Appendix C - Single Family Detailed Results <br />Table 25: Single Family Mixed Fuel Efficiency Package Cost -Effectiveness Results <br />">1" = indicates cases where there is both first cost savings and annual utility bill savings. <br />57 <br />2019-08-01 <br />362 <br />BASECASE <br />Non -Preempted <br />Equipment <br />- Preempted <br />p <br />v <br />C a <br />a 0 <br />a <br />C <br />." <br />u <br />y <br />a <br />U <br />\ <br />m <br />p <br />aLc <br />y <br />a <br />U <br />\ <br />m <br />W <br />C <br />G/ W <br />ei OYl <br />N <br />p <br />W <br />C <br />C <br />d <br />C M <br />2 C <br />0. <br />C <br />E '� <br />N <br />Q <br />� <br />= <br />U <br />\ <br />m <br />Ui <br />C <br />d <br />C C <br />Ol C <br />a <br />C <br />E '� <br />N <br />Q <br />� <br />_ <br />U <br />\ <br />m <br />.0 <br />L <br />' <br />Y <br />+M+ <br />U <br />u <br />U f0 <br />U w <br />Y <br />m C <br />it <br />C <br />> a+ <br />� <br />U <br />U f0 <br />M <br />U w <br />Y <br />m C <br />4j <br />G <br />> a+ <br />CZ <br />utility <br />c <br />¢ v° <br />a> <br />C <br />o <br />a> <br />co <br />p m <br />o <br />w <br />w <br />a <br />> <br />M <br />D M <br />Y <br />W W <br />U <br />- V1 <br />d <br />W W <br />W W <br />L <br />- Vf <br />d <br />O oc <br />W W <br />W W <br />L <br />- Vl <br />d <br />O cc <br />cc <br />1 <br />PG&E <br />32.5 <br />54.2 <br />23 <br />3.0 <br />3.3 <br />27.9 <br />49.0 <br />5.3 <br />18.8% <br />2.5 <br />3.2 <br />3.4 <br />2.8 <br />26.0 <br />47.3 <br />6.9 <br />25.1% <br />2.3 <br />3.2 <br />4.9 <br />4.1 <br />2 <br />PG&E <br />25.0 <br />46.0 <br />12 <br />2.2 <br />2.8 <br />22.0 <br />42.7 <br />3.3 <br />16.3% <br />1.9 <br />2.8 <br />1.6 <br />1.7 <br />21.8 <br />42.6 <br />3.3 <br />16.4% <br />1.9 <br />2.8 <br />3.8 <br />3.6 <br />3 <br />PG&E <br />23.9 <br />46.9 <br />10 <br />1.9 <br />2.7 <br />21.3 <br />43.9 <br />3.0 <br />16.7% <br />1.6 <br />2.7 <br />1.3 <br />1.3 <br />20.1 <br />42.8 <br />4.1 <br />22.8% <br />1.5 <br />2.7 <br />1.9 <br />2.0 <br />4 <br />PG&E <br />23.1 <br />44.9 <br />8 <br />1.9 <br />2.7 <br />20.8 <br />42.4 <br />2.5 <br />13.9% <br />1.7 <br />2.7 <br />0.9 <br />1.2 <br />20.5 <br />42.2 <br />2.7 <br />14.9% <br />1.6 <br />2.7 <br />2.4 <br />2.7 <br />5 <br />PG&E <br />22.2 <br />44.4 <br />10 <br />1.8 <br />2.6 <br />19.7 <br />41.7 <br />2.7 <br />16.7% <br />1.6 <br />2.5 <br />1.1 <br />1.2 <br />19.7 <br />41.7 <br />2.6 <br />16.2% <br />1.5 <br />2.5 <br />2.3 <br />2.5 <br />5 <br />PG&E/SoCalGas <br />22.2 <br />44.4 <br />10 <br />1.8 <br />2.6 <br />19.7 <br />41.7 <br />2.7 <br />16.7% <br />1.6 <br />2.5 <br />0.9 <br />1.2 <br />19.7 <br />41.7 <br />2.6 <br />16.2% <br />1.5 <br />2.5 <br />2.0 <br />2.5 <br />6 <br />SCE/SoCalGas <br />23.3 <br />49.9 <br />10 <br />1.6 <br />2.7 <br />21.5 <br />47.8 <br />2.0 <br />12.1% <br />1.5 <br />2.7 <br />0.7 <br />1.2 <br />21.5 <br />47.9 <br />2.0 <br />11.8% <br />1.4 <br />2.7 <br />1.6 <br />2.0 <br />7 <br />SDG&E <br />20.3 <br />49.1 <br />5 <br />1.3 <br />2.6 <br />20.3 <br />49.1 <br />0.0 <br />0.0% <br />1.3 <br />2.6 <br />- <br />- <br />18.8 <br />47.6 <br />1.5 <br />12.4% <br />1.2 <br />2.6 <br />1.5 <br />1.4 <br />8 <br />SCE/SoCalGas <br />21.3 <br />46.9 <br />10 <br />1.4 <br />2.9 <br />20.1 <br />45.6 <br />1.3 <br />7.7% <br />1.3 <br />2.9 <br />0.6 <br />1.4 <br />19.7 <br />45.3 <br />1.6 <br />9.4% <br />1.3 <br />2.9 <br />1.3 <br />1.8 <br />9 <br />SCE/SoCalGas <br />24.5 <br />47.7 <br />13 <br />1.5 <br />2.9 <br />22.3 <br />45.1 <br />2.6 <br />11.7% <br />1.5 <br />2.9 <br />0.7 <br />2.0 <br />21.9 <br />44.8 <br />2.9 <br />13.4% <br />1.4 <br />2.9 <br />1.8 <br />3.7 <br />10 <br />SCE/SoCalGas <br />24.2 <br />46.3 <br />10 <br />1.6 <br />3.0 <br />21.7 <br />43.1 <br />3.2 <br />14.3% <br />1.5 <br />3.0 <br />0.6 <br />1.3 <br />21.5 <br />43.1 <br />3.2 <br />14.6% <br />1.4 <br />3.0 <br />2.0 <br />3.8 <br />10 <br />SDG&E <br />24.2 <br />46.3 <br />10 <br />1.6 <br />3.0 <br />21.7 <br />43.1 <br />3.2 <br />14.3% <br />1.5 <br />3.0 <br />0.8 <br />1.3 <br />21.5 <br />43.1 <br />3.2 <br />14.6% <br />1.4 <br />3.0 <br />2.6 <br />3.8 <br />11 <br />PG&E <br />24.6 <br />44.9 <br />11 <br />2.1 <br />3.6 <br />21.3 <br />40.6 <br />4.3 <br />16.4% <br />1.9 <br />3.4 <br />0.8 <br />1.2 <br />20.7 <br />39.9 <br />5.1 <br />19.2% <br />1.8 <br />3.4 <br />2.5 <br />3.7 <br />12 <br />PG&E <br />25.5 <br />44.8 <br />12 <br />2.1 <br />3.0 <br />22.5 <br />41.3 <br />3.5 <br />14.9% <br />1.9 <br />2.9 <br />1.2 <br />1.8 <br />22.5 <br />41.4 <br />3.4 <br />14.4% <br />1.9 <br />3.0 <br />3.3 <br />4.6 <br />13 <br />PG&E <br />25.7 <br />46.5 <br />11 <br />2.0 <br />3.8 <br />22.2 <br />41.9 <br />4.6 <br />16.9% <br />1.8 <br />3.6 <br />0.8 <br />1.3 <br />21.2 <br />40.7 <br />5.8 <br />21.4% <br />1.7 <br />3.6 <br />5.3 <br />8.4 <br />14 <br />SCE/SoCalGas <br />25.3 <br />46.3 <br />15 <br />2.3 <br />3.2 <br />21.5 <br />41.3 <br />5.0 <br />18.5% <br />2.1 <br />3.0 <br />1.6 <br />2.5 <br />20.8 <br />40.4 <br />5.8 <br />21.7% <br />2.0 <br />3.0 <br />4.0 <br />6.1 <br />14 <br />SDG&E <br />25.3 <br />46.3 <br />15 <br />2.3 <br />3.2 <br />21.5 <br />41.3 <br />5.0 <br />18.5% <br />2.1 <br />3.0 <br />1.9 <br />2.5 <br />20.8 <br />40.4 <br />5.8 <br />21.7% <br />2.0 <br />3.0 <br />4.9 <br />6.1 <br />15 <br />SCE/SoCalGas <br />22.4 <br />49.1 <br />11 <br />1.7 <br />5.4 <br />19.7 <br />44.3 <br />4.8 <br />14.8% <br />1.6 <br />5.0 <br />1.0 <br />1.6 <br />19.5 <br />44.1 <br />5.0 <br />15.4% <br />1.5 <br />5.0 <br />>1 <br />>1 <br />16 <br />PG&E <br />30.4 <br />48.9 <br />22 <br />3.3 <br />2.7 <br />25.0 <br />43.5 <br />5.4 <br />20.6% <br />2.6 <br />2.7 <br />1.6 <br />1.5 <br />1 24.8 <br />42.7 <br />6.2 <br />23.5% <br />2.7 <br />2.6 <br />2.2 <br />2.2 <br />">1" = indicates cases where there is both first cost savings and annual utility bill savings. <br />57 <br />2019-08-01 <br />362 <br />