Laserfiche WebLink
7.A. - Page 123 of 285 <br />2019 Energy Efficiency Ordinance Cost-effectiveness Study <br />Table 38: Multifamily All -Electric Efficiency Package Cost -Effectiveness Results <br />">1" = indicates cases where there is both first cost savings and annual utility bill savings. <br />70 <br />2019-08-01 <br />375 <br />BASECASE <br />Non -Preempted <br />Equipment - Preempted <br />cc <br />v <br />oc <br />a <br />ooc <br />cc <br />o <br />W <br />4, <br />H W <br />bb <br />L <br />L <br />U <br />0 <br />W <br />L <br />L <br />M <br />cc <br />LW <br />W <br />L <br />L <br />U <br />M <br />OC <br />T <br />= L <br />H <br />CL <br />N <br />N <br />O" <br />T <br />T <br />O. <br />CL <br />N <br />v <br />Q <br />\ <br />m <br />\ <br />0 <br />�. <br />T <br />Q= <br />O. <br />N <br />y <br />\ <br />m <br />\ <br />C <br />v <br />N <br />L m <br />0 <br />3 <br />_ <br />O <br />v <br />= O <br />d <br />O <br />E •� <br />O <br />C <br />3 <br />m <br />_ <br />C <br />v <br />O C <br />v <br />E •� <br />O <br />C <br />3 <br />m <br />70 <br />•V <br />J Q <br />U �„� <br />Y �_ <br />f0 <br />•V <br />•V L <br />U a„� <br />Y <br />m <br />(O <br />•V <br />•V <br />0 <br />U a„� <br />Y �_ <br />m <br />O <br />w <br />Q W <br />rr> <br />O <br />m <br />O <br />iE <br />CCL <br />o <br />a> <br />m <br />O <br />0 <br />W <br />CCL <br />W <br />CCL <br />o <br />v> <br />7 <br />m <br />M <br />O m <br />0 <br />CZ <br />Utility <br />F- <br />W <br />U .1 <br />- in <br />a <br />W <br />W <br />C <br />_ <br />d' <br />G <br />C <br />_ 0 <br />a <br />01 <br />PG&E <br />41.1 <br />70.6 <br />36 <br />1.6 <br />15.9 <br />37.5 <br />67.0 <br />3.6 <br />14.6% <br />1.5 <br />15.9 <br />1.6 <br />1.4 <br />37.1 <br />67.3 <br />3.3 <br />18.4% <br />1.4 <br />15.9 <br />2.4 <br />2.3 <br />02 <br />PG&E <br />34.3 <br />63.4 <br />16 <br />1.4 <br />13.9 <br />32.4 <br />61.5 <br />1.9 <br />9.1% <br />1.3 <br />13.9 <br />1.7 <br />2.1 <br />31.1 <br />60.2 <br />3.2 <br />15.1% <br />1.3 <br />13.9 <br />1.6 <br />1.6 <br />03 <br />PG&E <br />33.5 <br />64.2 <br />14 <br />1.3 <br />13.5 <br />33.5 <br />64.2 <br />0.0 <br />0.0% <br />1.3 <br />13.5 <br />- <br />- <br />30.4 <br />61.5 <br />2.7 <br />19.5% <br />1.1 <br />13.5 <br />1.7 <br />1.6 <br />04 <br />PG&E <br />32.0 <br />61.4 <br />12 <br />1.3 <br />13.6 <br />30.5 <br />60.0 <br />1.4 <br />8.0% <br />1.2 <br />13.6 <br />1.4 <br />1.5 <br />29.7 <br />59.2 <br />2.2 <br />12.2% <br />1.2 <br />13.6 <br />1.2 <br />1.1 <br />05 <br />PG&E <br />34.7 <br />65.4 <br />16 <br />1.3 <br />12.6 <br />34.1 <br />64.8 <br />0.6 <br />3.4% <br />1.3 <br />12.6 <br />1.1 <br />0.9 <br />30.6 <br />61.8 <br />3.6 <br />23.5% <br />1.2 <br />12.6 <br />2.1 <br />2.0 <br />05 <br />PG&E/SoCalGas <br />34.7 <br />65.4 <br />16 <br />1.3 <br />12.6 <br />34.1 <br />64.8 <br />0.6 <br />3.4% <br />1.3 <br />12.6 <br />1.1 <br />0.9 <br />30.6 <br />61.8 <br />3.6 <br />23.5% <br />1.2 <br />12.6 <br />2.1 <br />2.0 <br />06 <br />SCE/SoCalGas <br />31.9 <br />65.9 <br />12 <br />1.3 <br />13.9 <br />30.9 <br />64.9 <br />1.0 <br />5.9% <br />1.3 <br />13.9 <br />0.7 <br />1.3 <br />29.8 <br />63.7 <br />2.2 <br />13.0% <br />1.2 <br />13.9 <br />1.6 <br />1.9 <br />07 <br />SDG&E <br />31.7 <br />66.6 <br />7 <br />1.2 <br />13.2 <br />31.1 <br />66.0 <br />0.6 <br />4.6% <br />1.2 <br />13.2 <br />0.6 <br />1.0 <br />29.7 <br />64.7 <br />1.9 <br />13.6% <br />1.1 <br />13.2 <br />1.6 <br />1.7 <br />08 <br />SCE/SoCalGas <br />29.8 <br />63.6 <br />10 <br />1.3 <br />14.6 <br />28.6 <br />62.4 <br />1.2 <br />6.5% <br />1.2 <br />14.6 <br />0.9 <br />1.7 <br />27.9 <br />61.7 <br />1.9 <br />10.3% <br />1.2 <br />14.6 <br />1.6 <br />1.8 <br />09 <br />SCE/SoCalGas <br />30.4 <br />61.9 <br />13 <br />1.3 <br />14.7 <br />28.7 <br />60.3 <br />1.6 <br />8.1% <br />1.3 <br />14.7 <br />1.3 <br />2.7 <br />28.8 <br />60.4 <br />1.5 <br />7.4% <br />1.2 <br />14.7 <br />1.6 <br />1.6 <br />10 <br />SCE/SoCalGas <br />31.2 <br />61.3 <br />11 <br />1.4 <br />15.1 <br />29.3 <br />59.5 <br />1.8 <br />8.7% <br />1.3 <br />15.1 <br />1.2 <br />2.0 <br />29.3 <br />59.5 <br />1.8 <br />8.6% <br />1.3 <br />15.1 <br />1.7 <br />2.0 <br />10 <br />SDG&E <br />31.2 <br />61.3 <br />11 <br />1.4 <br />15.1 <br />29.3 <br />59.5 <br />1.8 <br />8.7% <br />1.3 <br />15.1 <br />1.5 <br />2.0 <br />29.3 <br />59.5 <br />1.8 <br />8.6% <br />1.3 <br />15.1 <br />2.0 <br />2.0 <br />11 <br />PG&E <br />31.9 <br />60.6 <br />12 <br />1.4 <br />16.6 <br />28.5 <br />57.1 <br />3.5 <br />13.1% <br />1.3 <br />16.6 <br />1.4 <br />1.6 <br />28.1 <br />56.7 <br />3.9 <br />14.4% <br />1.3 <br />16.6 <br />2.0 <br />2.3 <br />12 <br />PG&E <br />32.0 <br />59.9 <br />13 <br />1.3 <br />14.9 <br />29.4 <br />57.3 <br />2.6 <br />11.4% <br />1.2 <br />14.9 <br />0.9 <br />1.1 <br />29.0 <br />57.0 <br />2.9 <br />13.0% <br />1.2 <br />14.9 <br />1.6 <br />1.6 <br />13 <br />PG&E <br />32.1 <br />60.5 <br />13 <br />1.4 <br />17.5 <br />28.8 <br />57.2 <br />3.3 <br />12.6% <br />1.2 <br />17.5 <br />1.3 <br />1.6 <br />28.3 <br />56.7 <br />3.8 <br />14.3% <br />1.2 <br />17.5 <br />2.0 <br />2.3 <br />14 <br />SCE/SoCalGas <br />32.5 <br />61.6 <br />16 <br />1.7 <br />14.6 <br />28.9 <br />57.9 <br />3.7 <br />13.8% <br />1.6 <br />14.6 <br />1.2 <br />1.6 <br />28.7 <br />57.8 <br />3.8 <br />14.3% <br />1.6 <br />14.6 <br />1.6 <br />2.2 <br />14 <br />SDG&E <br />32.5 <br />61.6 <br />16 <br />1.7 <br />14.6 <br />28.9 <br />57.9 <br />3.7 <br />13.8% <br />1.6 <br />14.6 <br />1.5 <br />1.6 <br />28.7 <br />57.8 <br />3.8 <br />14.3% <br />1.6 <br />14.6 <br />2.0 <br />2.2 <br />15 <br />SCE/SoCalGas <br />28.2 <br />61.0 <br />8 <br />1.8 <br />21.6 <br />23.9 <br />56.6 <br />4.4 <br />14.2% <br />1.6 <br />21.6 <br />1.5 <br />2.3 <br />21.9 <br />54.6 <br />6.4 <br />20.6% <br />1.5 <br />21.6 <br />1.2 <br />1.7 <br />16 <br />PG&E <br />40.2 <br />66.6 <br />39 <br />1.9 <br />13.4 <br />36.2 <br />62.5 <br />4.1 <br />15.0% <br />1.7 <br />13.4 <br />2.1 <br />2.1 <br />37.1 <br />63.4 <br />3.2 <br />11.4% <br />1.7 <br />13.4 <br />1.6 <br />1.7 <br />">1" = indicates cases where there is both first cost savings and annual utility bill savings. <br />70 <br />2019-08-01 <br />375 <br />