|
7.A. - Page 207 of 285
<br />2019 Nonresidential New Construction Reach Code Cost Effectiveness Study
<br />Figure 23. Cost Effectiveness for Medium Office Package 3C - All -Electric + HE
<br />CZ
<br />Utility
<br />Elec
<br />Savings
<br />(kWh)
<br />Gas
<br />Savings
<br />(therms)
<br />GHG
<br />Reductions
<br />(mtons)
<br />Comp-
<br />liance
<br />Margin
<br />Incremental
<br />Package Cost
<br />Lifecycle
<br />Utility Cost
<br />Savings
<br />$TDV
<br />Savings
<br />B/C
<br />Ratio
<br />(On-
<br />bill)
<br />B/C
<br />Ratio
<br />(TDV)
<br />NPV (On -
<br />bill)
<br />NPV (TDV)
<br />Package 3C: All -Electric + HE
<br />CZ01
<br />PG&E
<br />-53,390
<br />4967
<br />10.2
<br />-14%
<br />($43,987)
<br />($93,740)
<br />($57,752)
<br />0.5
<br />0.8
<br />($49,753)
<br />($13,765)
<br />CZ02
<br />PG&E
<br />-45,916
<br />3868
<br />6.1
<br />-5%
<br />($22,722)
<br />($77,212)
<br />($26,394)
<br />0.3
<br />0.9
<br />($54,490)
<br />($3,672)
<br />CZ03
<br />PG&E
<br />-34,656
<br />3142
<br />6.0
<br />-6%
<br />($38,261)
<br />($45,796)
<br />($25,153)
<br />0.8
<br />1.5
<br />($7,535)
<br />$13,108
<br />CZ04
<br />PG&E
<br />-43,248
<br />3759
<br />6.3
<br />-3%
<br />($15,229)
<br />($56,932)
<br />($18,996)
<br />0.3
<br />0.8
<br />($41,703)
<br />($3,767)
<br />CZ04-2
<br />CPAU
<br />-43,248
<br />3759
<br />6.3
<br />-3%
<br />($15,229)
<br />($5,298)
<br />($18,996)
<br />2.9
<br />0.8
<br />$9,932
<br />($3,767)
<br />CZ05
<br />PG&E
<br />-37,068
<br />3240
<br />5.4
<br />-6%
<br />($40,434)
<br />($38,330)
<br />($29,544)
<br />1.1
<br />1.4
<br />$2,104
<br />$10,890
<br />CZ06
<br />SCE
<br />-22,805
<br />2117
<br />4.0
<br />-2%
<br />($30,237)
<br />$39,812
<br />($9,594)
<br />>1
<br />3.2
<br />$70,050
<br />$20,644
<br />CZ06-2
<br />LADWP
<br />-22,805
<br />2117
<br />4.0
<br />-2%
<br />($30,237)
<br />$35,414
<br />($9,594)
<br />>1
<br />3.2
<br />$65,651
<br />$20,644
<br />CZ07
<br />SDG&E
<br />-7,646
<br />950
<br />2.5
<br />1%
<br />($22,564)
<br />$86,159
<br />$6,062
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$108,722
<br />$28,625
<br />CZ08
<br />SCE
<br />-9,761
<br />1219
<br />3.2
<br />1%
<br />($18,443)
<br />$37,375
<br />$8,305
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$55,818
<br />$26,748
<br />CZ08-2
<br />LADWP
<br />-9,761
<br />1219
<br />3.2
<br />1%
<br />($18,443)
<br />$29,973
<br />$8,305
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$48,416
<br />$26,748
<br />CZ09
<br />SCE
<br />-12,211
<br />1605
<br />4.5
<br />2%
<br />($10,282)
<br />$46,335
<br />$13,364
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$56,617
<br />$23,646
<br />CZ09-2
<br />LADWP
<br />-12,211
<br />1605
<br />4.5
<br />2%
<br />($10,282)
<br />$37,030
<br />$13,364
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$47,313
<br />$23,646
<br />CZ10
<br />SDG&E
<br />-21,642
<br />2053
<br />3.7
<br />-1%
<br />$11,340
<br />$84,901
<br />($3,818)
<br />7.5
<br />-0.3
<br />$73,561
<br />($15,158)
<br />CZ10-2
<br />SCE
<br />-21,642
<br />2053
<br />3.7
<br />-1%
<br />$11,340
<br />$40,659
<br />($3,818)
<br />3.6
<br />-0.3
<br />$29,319
<br />($15,158)
<br />CZ11
<br />PG&E
<br />-32,052
<br />3062
<br />5.9
<br />0%
<br />($8,519)
<br />($29,013)
<br />($3,007)
<br />0.3
<br />2.8
<br />($20,495)
<br />$5,512
<br />CZ12
<br />PG&E
<br />-36,926
<br />3327
<br />6.0
<br />-1%
<br />($15,443)
<br />($48,955)
<br />($9,546)
<br />0.3
<br />1.6
<br />($33,511)
<br />$5,898
<br />CZ12-2
<br />SMUD
<br />-36,926
<br />3327
<br />6.0
<br />-1%
<br />($15,443)
<br />$9,916
<br />($9,546)
<br />>1
<br />1.6
<br />$25,359
<br />$5,898
<br />CZ13
<br />PG&E
<br />-31,253
<br />3063
<br />6.3
<br />0%
<br />($7,257)
<br />($27,782)
<br />($3,055)
<br />0.3
<br />2.4
<br />($20,525)
<br />$4,202
<br />CZ14
<br />SDG&E
<br />-36,402
<br />3266
<br />5.7
<br />-1%
<br />($10,651)
<br />$61,605
<br />($9,832)
<br />>1
<br />1.1
<br />$72,256
<br />$819
<br />CZ14-2
<br />SCE
<br />-36,402
<br />3266
<br />5.7
<br />-1%
<br />($10,651)
<br />$30,625
<br />($9,832)
<br />>1
<br />1.1
<br />$41,276
<br />$819
<br />CZ15
<br />SCE
<br />-4,775
<br />1537
<br />6.0
<br />3%
<br />$28,927
<br />$52,955
<br />$32,790
<br />1.8
<br />1.1
<br />$24,028
<br />$3,863
<br />CZ16
<br />PG&E
<br />-90,949
<br />6185
<br />6.5
<br />-26%
<br />($8,467)
<br />($194,115)
<br />($142,041)
<br />0.0
<br />0.1
<br />($185,648)
<br />($133,574)
<br />CZ16-2
<br />LADWP
<br />-90,949
<br />6185
<br />6.5
<br />-26%
<br />($8,467)
<br />$37,127
<br />($142,041)
<br />>1
<br />0.1
<br />$45,594
<br />($133,574)
<br />32
<br />2019-07-25
<br />459
<br />
|