AgdaPkt 2010-02-01 clsd and regular

Browse Search

7A - ATTACHMENT NO.3 Saltworks Proposal- Water Group Summary Report (22 January 2010) Page 62 Because the delivery of water for the Saltworks project would not have a net impact on Delta pumping, the water team concludes that the Saltworks EIR would not have to analyze in detail the Saltworks project's impact within the Delta. For this reason, the water team preliminarily concludes that the analysis would not have to reach into and beyond the operation of the Delta pumps. Rather, the EI R would have to provide sufficient information to demonstrate that the proposed water transfer, and resulting shifts in timing of deliveries, would not result in an impact on Delta pumping. This preliminary conclusion deserves additional attention, however, given the complexity of any analysis that includes consideration of the impacts of Delta pumping. At a minimum, further analysis should be performed to confirm the water team's preliminary conclusion. 3.8.5 Preliminary Conclusions about Proposed Water Transfer As noted above, DMB's proposal involves reaching agreement with or obtaining approvals from the City and other public agencies. In the event Redwood City decides to move forward with the CEQA process, the water team recommends (1) obtaining from DMB additional details regarding its proposal, and (2) contacting the other involved public agencies. The information provided by DMB and other agencies would then be included in the Water Supply Assessment for the Saltworks project. Indeed, the water team recommends that, if the City decides to proceed with the environmental review process, the City should ensure that the Saltworks EIR includes a WSA that provides a robust analysis of DMB's proposed water transfer. It will be important to consult with other involved public agencies (e.g., SFPUC, BAWSCA, OWR) , so that the EIR includes the information the other agencies will need in order to decide whether to approve the agreements necessary for the proposal to proceed. In addition, operational details concerning storage, treatment and delivery would have to be determined, both by Redwood City, and by any intermediary agencies. There is no way to ensure that other agencies will enter into agreements or otherwise approve OMB's proposal. Nonetheless, the water team preliminarily concludes that OMB's proposal is potentially feasible. As explained above, the Nickel water appears to be quite reliable. SCVWO's acquisition of 2,000 acre-feet of Nickel water in 2009 demonstrates that such a transfer can be accomplished. The amount of Nickel water owned by OMB is more than sufficient to meet the needs of the Saltworks project. Indeed, sufficient water is available to help augment and diversify supplies available to both the City and whatever other water retailers are involved in the transaction. The amount of water to be provided would be the subject of negotiations between DMB, the City, and other involved agencies. To the extent DMB would agree to commit more of the Nickel water than the Saltworks project itself would require, the City's overall water supply could benefit from the Saltworks project. 3.9 Summary of Findings Regarding Water Supply The DMB Supply Report identifies a suite of water supply options for the Saltworks project. Potable supplies include Redwood City's SFPUC supply, local groundwater, and supply achieved through offsetting potable demand locally or regionally to make that supply available for the Project. Non-potable supplies include recycled water, graywater and rainwater. After the publication of the DMB Supply Report, OMB identified another potable water supply option for the project - a surface water transfer. OMB has identified to the water 55