|
7.A. - Page 92 of 285
<br />2019 Energy Efficiency Ordinance Cost-effectiveness Study
<br />'Red values in parentheses indicate an increase in utility bill costs or an incremental first cost for the all -electric home.
<br />z">1" indicates cases where there are both first cost savings and annual utility bill savings.
<br />Table 17: Comparison of Multifamily On -Bill Cost Effectiveness Results with Additional PV
<br />Per Dwelling Unit
<br />Neutral Cost
<br />On -Bill Cost-effectiveness'
<br />TDV Cost-effectiveness
<br />PV Equipment
<br />PV Equipment
<br />Average Annual UtilitV Bill
<br />Lifetime NPV
<br />Capacity Utility Bill Cost On -Bill
<br />Lifetime NPV
<br />CZ
<br />Utility
<br />Savings
<br />(kW) Savings Savings B/C Ratio
<br />01
<br />PG&E
<br />2.7 -($1,057) +$0 0
<br />3.0 +$1,198 -($1,052) 1.1
<br />Net
<br />Equipment
<br />On -Bill
<br />Equipment
<br />TDV
<br />Natural
<br />Utility
<br />Utility Bill
<br />Cost
<br />B/C
<br />TDV Cost
<br />Cost
<br />B/C
<br />CZ
<br />Utility
<br />Electricity
<br />Gas
<br />Savings
<br />Savings
<br />Savings
<br />Ratio2
<br />Savings
<br />Savings
<br />Ratio
<br />Neutral
<br />Cost Package
<br />01
<br />PG&E
<br />-($228)
<br />+$193
<br />-($35)
<br />-($1,057)
<br />+$0
<br />0
<br />-($2,267)
<br />+$3,564
<br />1.6
<br />02
<br />PG&E
<br />-($115)
<br />+$162
<br />+$47
<br />+$1,399
<br />+$0
<br />>1
<br />+$59
<br />+$3,563
<br />>1
<br />03
<br />PG&E
<br />-($81)
<br />+$142
<br />+$61
<br />+$1,843
<br />+$0
<br />>1
<br />+$138
<br />+$3,562
<br />>1
<br />04
<br />PG&E
<br />-($64)
<br />+$144
<br />+$80
<br />+$2,402
<br />+$0
<br />>1
<br />+$983
<br />+$3,563
<br />>1
<br />05
<br />PG&E
<br />-($90)
<br />+$140
<br />+$50
<br />+$1,490
<br />+$0
<br />>1
<br />-($152)
<br />+$3,564
<br />23.4
<br />05
<br />PG&E/SoCalGas
<br />-($90)
<br />+$178
<br />+$87
<br />+$2,620
<br />+$0
<br />>1
<br />-($152)
<br />+$3,564
<br />23.4
<br />06
<br />SCE/SoCalGas
<br />-($90)
<br />+$161
<br />+$71
<br />+$2,144
<br />+$0
<br />>1
<br />+$1,612
<br />+$3,562
<br />>1
<br />07
<br />SDG&E
<br />-($32)
<br />+$136
<br />+$105
<br />+$3,135
<br />+$0
<br />>1
<br />+$1,886
<br />+$3,560
<br />>1
<br />08
<br />SCE/SoCalGas
<br />-($67)
<br />+$157
<br />+$90
<br />+$2,705
<br />+$0
<br />>1
<br />+$1,955
<br />+$3,564
<br />>1
<br />09
<br />SCE/SoCalGas
<br />-($71)
<br />+$159
<br />+$87
<br />+$2,623
<br />+$0
<br />>1
<br />+$1,924
<br />+$3,561
<br />>1
<br />10
<br />SCE/SoCalGas
<br />-($78)
<br />+$159
<br />+$81
<br />+$2,431
<br />+$0
<br />>1
<br />+$1,588
<br />+$3,561
<br />>1
<br />10
<br />SDG&E
<br />-($71)
<br />+$139
<br />+$68
<br />+$2,033
<br />+$0
<br />>1
<br />+$1,588
<br />+$3,561
<br />>1
<br />11
<br />PG&E
<br />-($93)
<br />+$153
<br />+$59
<br />+$1,783
<br />+$0
<br />>1
<br />-($48)
<br />+$3,562
<br />74.0
<br />12
<br />PG&E
<br />-($82)
<br />+$155
<br />+$73
<br />+$2,184
<br />+$0
<br />>1
<br />+$739
<br />+$3,564
<br />>1
<br />13
<br />PG&E
<br />-($79)
<br />+$146
<br />+$68
<br />+$2,034
<br />+$0
<br />>1
<br />+$310
<br />+$3,560
<br />>1
<br />14
<br />SCE/SoCalGas
<br />-($141)
<br />+$187
<br />+$45
<br />+$1,359
<br />+$0
<br />>1
<br />+$747
<br />+$3,562
<br />>1
<br />14
<br />SDG&E
<br />-($137)
<br />+$175
<br />+$38
<br />+$1,131
<br />+$0
<br />>1
<br />+$747
<br />+$3,562
<br />>1
<br />15
<br />SCE/SoCalGas
<br />-($50)
<br />+$142
<br />+$92
<br />+$2,771
<br />+$0
<br />>1
<br />+$1,738
<br />+$3,560
<br />>1
<br />16
<br />PG&E
<br />-($194)
<br />+$224
<br />+$30
<br />1 +$900
<br />+$0
<br />>1
<br />-($1,382)
<br />+$3,564
<br />2.6
<br />'Red values in parentheses indicate an increase in utility bill costs or an incremental first cost for the all -electric home.
<br />z">1" indicates cases where there are both first cost savings and annual utility bill savings.
<br />Table 17: Comparison of Multifamily On -Bill Cost Effectiveness Results with Additional PV
<br />Per Dwelling Unit
<br />39
<br />2019-08-01
<br />344
<br />Neutral Cost
<br />Min. Cost Effectiveness
<br />PV Equipment
<br />PV Equipment
<br />Capacity Utility Bill Cost On -Bill
<br />Capacity Utility Bill Cost On -Bill
<br />CZ
<br />Utility
<br />(kW) Savings Savings B/C Ratio
<br />(kW) Savings Savings B/C Ratio
<br />01
<br />PG&E
<br />2.7 -($1,057) +$0 0
<br />3.0 +$1,198 -($1,052) 1.1
<br />39
<br />2019-08-01
<br />344
<br />
|