|
7.A. - Page 205 of 285
<br />2019 Nonresidential New Construction Reach Code Cost Effectiveness Study
<br />Figure 21. Cost Effectiveness for Medium Office Package 3A - All -Electric + EE
<br />CZ
<br />Utility
<br />El
<br />Savings
<br />(kWh)
<br />Gas Savings
<br />(therms)
<br />GHG
<br />Reductions
<br />(mtons)
<br />Comp-
<br />Hance
<br />Margin
<br />Incremental
<br />Package
<br />Cost
<br />Lifecycle
<br />Utility Cost
<br />Savings
<br />$TDV
<br />Savings
<br />B/C
<br />Ratio
<br />(On -bill)
<br />B/C
<br />Ratio
<br />(TDV)
<br />NPV (On-
<br />bill)
<br />NPV
<br />(TDV)
<br />Package 3A: All -Electric + EE
<br />CZ01
<br />PG&E
<br />-19,115
<br />4967
<br />19.4
<br />7%
<br />($20,604)
<br />$20,630
<br />$28,112
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$41,234
<br />$48,716
<br />CZ02
<br />PG&E
<br />-11,811
<br />3868
<br />15.2
<br />10%
<br />($7,046)
<br />$39,260
<br />$58,563
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$46,306
<br />$65,609
<br />CZ03
<br />PG&E
<br />2,530
<br />3142
<br />16.2
<br />16%
<br />($15,681)
<br />$85,241
<br />$68,682
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$100,922
<br />$84,363
<br />CZ04
<br />PG&E
<br />-10,839
<br />3759
<br />14.8
<br />9%
<br />($2,363)
<br />$59,432
<br />$58,420
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$61,795
<br />$60,783
<br />CZ04-2
<br />CPAU
<br />-10,839
<br />3759
<br />14.8
<br />9%
<br />($2,363)
<br />$70,680
<br />$58,420
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$73,043
<br />$60,783
<br />CZ05
<br />PG&E
<br />-2,316
<br />3240
<br />14.6
<br />12%
<br />($17,854)
<br />$85,380
<br />$58,802
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$103,234
<br />$76,656
<br />CZ06
<br />SCE
<br />15,399
<br />2117
<br />14.3
<br />18%
<br />($9,503)
<br />$114,962
<br />$89,921
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$124,466
<br />$99,425
<br />CZ06-2
<br />LADWP
<br />15,399
<br />2117
<br />14.3
<br />18%
<br />($9,503)
<br />$82,389
<br />$89,921
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$91,893
<br />$99,425
<br />CZ07
<br />SDG&E
<br />33,318
<br />950
<br />13.8
<br />20%
<br />($3,676)
<br />$256,704
<br />$111,399
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$260,380
<br />$115,076
<br />CZ08
<br />SCE
<br />30,231
<br />1219
<br />14.2
<br />18%
<br />($2,124)
<br />$110,144
<br />$111,781
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$112,268
<br />$113,906
<br />CZ08-2
<br />LADWP
<br />30,231
<br />1219
<br />14.2
<br />18%
<br />($2,124)
<br />$76,069
<br />$111,781
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$78,194
<br />$113,906
<br />CZ09
<br />SCE
<br />24,283
<br />1605
<br />14.3
<br />15%
<br />$3,547
<br />$119,824
<br />$108,249
<br />33.8
<br />30.5
<br />$116,277
<br />$104,702
<br />CZ09-2
<br />LADWP
<br />24,283
<br />1605
<br />14.3
<br />15%
<br />$3,547
<br />$83,549
<br />$108,249
<br />23.6
<br />30.5
<br />$80,001
<br />$104,702
<br />CZ10
<br />SDG&E
<br />12,344
<br />2053
<br />12.6
<br />13%
<br />$18,748
<br />$230,553
<br />$82,905
<br />12.3
<br />4.4
<br />$211,806
<br />$64,158
<br />CZ10-2
<br />SCE
<br />12,344
<br />2053
<br />12.6
<br />13%
<br />$18,748
<br />$105,898
<br />$82,905
<br />5.6
<br />4.4
<br />$87,150
<br />$64,158
<br />CZ11
<br />PG&E
<br />929
<br />3062
<br />14.5
<br />10%
<br />$2,662
<br />$85,988
<br />$75,030
<br />32.3
<br />28.2
<br />$83,326
<br />$72,368
<br />CZ12
<br />PG&E
<br />-3,419
<br />3327
<br />14.8
<br />10%
<br />($1,694)
<br />$68,866
<br />$69,589
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$70,560
<br />$71,283
<br />CZ12-2
<br />SMUD
<br />-3,419
<br />3327
<br />14.8
<br />10%
<br />($1,694)
<br />$71,761
<br />$69,589
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$73,455
<br />$71,283
<br />CZ13
<br />PG&E
<br />1,398
<br />3063
<br />14.8
<br />9%
<br />$3,923
<br />$89,799
<br />$71,307
<br />22.9
<br />18.2
<br />$85,875
<br />$67,384
<br />CZ14
<br />SDG&E
<br />-5,469
<br />3266
<br />13.5
<br />9%
<br />$1,493
<br />$206,840
<br />$69,016
<br />138.6
<br />46.2
<br />$205,347
<br />$67,523
<br />CZ14-2
<br />SCE
<br />-5,469
<br />3266
<br />13.5
<br />9%
<br />$1,493
<br />$94,143
<br />$69,016
<br />63.1
<br />46.2
<br />$92,650
<br />$67,523
<br />CZ15
<br />SCE
<br />25,375
<br />1537
<br />13.7
<br />10%
<br />$30,474
<br />$114,909
<br />$104,335
<br />3.8
<br />3.4
<br />$84,435
<br />$73,862
<br />CZ16
<br />PG&E
<br />-65,877
<br />6185
<br />12.7
<br />-15%
<br />$2,553
<br />($91,477)
<br />($85,673)
<br />-35.8
<br />-33.6
<br />($94,030)
<br />($88,226)
<br />CZ16-2
<br />LADWP
<br />-65,877
<br />6185
<br />12.7
<br />-15%
<br />$2,553
<br />$72,780
<br />($85,673)
<br />28.5
<br />-33.6
<br />$70,227
<br />($88,226)
<br />2019-07-25
<br />457
<br />
|