|
7.A. - Page 213 of 285
<br />2019 Nonresidential New Construction Reach Code Cost Effectiveness Study
<br />Figure 28. Cost Effectiveness for Medium Retail Package 3A - All -Electric + EE
<br />CZ
<br />Utility
<br />El
<br />Savings
<br />(kWh)
<br />Gas Savings
<br />(therms)
<br />GHG
<br />Reductions
<br />(mtons)
<br />Comp-
<br />Hance
<br />Margin
<br />Incremental
<br />Package Cost
<br />Lifecycle
<br />Utility Cost
<br />Savings
<br />$TDV
<br />Savings
<br />B/C
<br />Ratio
<br />(On -bill)
<br />B/C
<br />Ratio
<br />(TDV)
<br />NPV (On-
<br />bill)
<br />NPV
<br />(TDV)
<br />Package 3A: All -Electric + EE
<br />CZ01
<br />PG&E
<br />-5,478
<br />3893
<br />20.64
<br />15%
<br />($20,336)
<br />$63,593
<br />$51,224
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$83,929
<br />$71,560
<br />CZ02
<br />PG&E
<br />2,843
<br />2448
<br />14.58
<br />13%
<br />($21,895)
<br />$74,997
<br />$56,893
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$96,892
<br />$78,788
<br />CZ03
<br />PG&E
<br />7,791
<br />1868
<br />12.73
<br />16%
<br />($18,542)
<br />$68,968
<br />$56,586
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$87,511
<br />$75,128
<br />CZ04
<br />PG&E
<br />8,572
<br />1706
<br />11.89
<br />14%
<br />($17,327)
<br />$81,957
<br />$57,904
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$99,284
<br />$75,231
<br />CZ04-2
<br />CPAU
<br />8,572
<br />1706
<br />11.89
<br />14%
<br />($17,327)
<br />$63,082
<br />$57,904
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$80,408
<br />$75,231
<br />CZ05
<br />PG&E
<br />6,973
<br />1746
<br />11.68
<br />15%
<br />($19,938)
<br />$63,677
<br />$51,949
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$83,615
<br />$71,887
<br />CZ06
<br />SCE
<br />7,431
<br />1002
<br />7.72
<br />11%
<br />($19,050)
<br />$47,072
<br />$42,610
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$66,122
<br />$61,660
<br />CZ06-2
<br />LADWP
<br />7,431
<br />1002
<br />7.72
<br />11%
<br />($19,050)
<br />$37,078
<br />$42,610
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$56,128
<br />$61,660
<br />CZ07
<br />SDG&E
<br />14,350
<br />522
<br />6.98
<br />13%
<br />($18,193)
<br />$127,461
<br />$50,828
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$145,654
<br />$69,021
<br />CZ08
<br />SCE
<br />8,524
<br />793
<br />6.90
<br />10%
<br />($24,210)
<br />$43,679
<br />$42,258
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$67,890
<br />$66,468
<br />CZ08-2
<br />LADWP
<br />8,524
<br />793
<br />6.90
<br />10%
<br />($24,210)
<br />$34,038
<br />$42,258
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$58,248
<br />$66,468
<br />CZ09
<br />SCE
<br />8,403
<br />970
<br />7.81
<br />10%
<br />($26,545)
<br />$47,819
<br />$47,356
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$74,364
<br />$73,901
<br />CZ09-2
<br />LADWP
<br />8,403
<br />970
<br />7.81
<br />10%
<br />($26,545)
<br />$37,934
<br />$47,356
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$64,478
<br />$73,901
<br />CZ10
<br />SDG&E
<br />11,737
<br />1262
<br />10.23
<br />12%
<br />($21,703)
<br />$137,436
<br />$58,761
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$159,139
<br />$80,464
<br />CZ10-2
<br />SCE
<br />11,737
<br />1262
<br />10.23
<br />12%
<br />($21,703)
<br />$58,257
<br />$58,761
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$79,959
<br />$80,464
<br />CZ11
<br />PG&E
<br />5,892
<br />2415
<br />15.13
<br />12%
<br />($26,633)
<br />$85,256
<br />$65,859
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$111,889
<br />$92,492
<br />CZ12
<br />PG&E
<br />5,548
<br />2309
<br />14.46
<br />12%
<br />($26,935)
<br />$80,631
<br />$63,903
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$107,566
<br />$90,838
<br />CZ12-2
<br />SMUD
<br />5,548
<br />2309
<br />14.46
<br />12%
<br />($26,935)
<br />$59,311
<br />$63,903
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$86,246
<br />$90,838
<br />CZ13
<br />PG&E
<br />10,184
<br />1983
<br />14.15
<br />14%
<br />($25,446)
<br />$110,105
<br />$80,604
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$135,551
<br />$106,050
<br />CZ14
<br />SDG&E
<br />16,583
<br />1672
<br />13.83
<br />15%
<br />($23,944)
<br />$171,200
<br />$88,471
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$195,145
<br />$112,415
<br />CZ14-2
<br />SCE
<br />16,583
<br />1672
<br />13.83
<br />15%
<br />($23,944)
<br />$656,178
<br />$159,604
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$680,122
<br />$183,548
<br />CZ15
<br />SCE
<br />23,642
<br />518
<br />9.44
<br />12%
<br />($26,832)
<br />$65,573
<br />$76,781
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$92,404
<br />$103,612
<br />CZ16
<br />PG&E
<br />-18,232
<br />4304
<br />19.80
<br />3%
<br />($23,059)
<br />$38,796
<br />$14,152
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$61,855
<br />$37,211
<br />CZ16-2
<br />LADWP
<br />-18,232
<br />4304
<br />19.80
<br />3%
<br />($23,059)
<br />$67,793
<br />$14,152
<br />>1
<br />>1
<br />$90,852
<br />$37,211
<br />2019-07-25
<br />465
<br />
|